18/08/2024
Demystifying Pool Filters: Sand vs. Cartridge & The Best Media Choices
Sand vs. Cartridge & The Best Media Choices
A crystal-clear pool isn’t just a visual treat – it’s a sign of a healthy swimming environment. And at the heart of this clarity lies your pool filter. But with various types and media options available, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Let’s explore the two most popular filter types – sand and cartridge – and the pros and cons of different media options, with a special spotlight on the benefits of sand filters.
Sand Filters: The Workhorse of Pool Filtration
Sand filters are the go-to choice for many pool owners due to their reliability, low maintenance, and cost-effectiveness. They work by passing water through a tank filled with sand, trapping debris as small as 20-40 microns.
Pros of Sand Filters:
- Low Maintenance: Backwashing is typically only needed every few weeks.
- Cost-Effective: Both the initial investment and ongoing maintenance costs are lower compared to cartridge filters.
- Durable: Sand filters can last for many years with proper care.
“Most media filters come with a 10-year warranty, which is longer than the lifespan of a standard cartridge filter (about 2 years). Glass media itself can last for 8–10 years because it’s made from recycled glass bottles. These are harder than standard glass and less prone to erosion. On the other hand, sand media breaks down after about 5 years. This means that media filters can last 5 times as long as cartridge filters and glass media twice as long as sand!”
Astral Pool
Pool & Spa Guides
Media Options for Sand Filters:
- Sand: The most common and affordable option, offers good filtration performance.
- Glass: A more expensive alternative, but offers superior filtration (down to 5 microns) and requires less frequent backwashing.
Cartridge Filters: Fine Filtration, Higher Maintenance
Cartridge filters use pleated fabric elements to trap debris, offering finer filtration (down to 10-15 microns) than standard sand filters.
-
Pros of Cartridge Filters:
- Superior Filtration: Ideal for those seeking the cleanest possible water.
- Energy Efficient: Can operate at lower flow rates, potentially saving on energy costs.
-
Cons of Cartridge Filters:
- Higher Maintenance: Cartridges require frequent cleaning and replacement, leading to higher ongoing costs.
- Higher Cost: Cartridge filters are generally more expensive long term.
Sand vs. Cartridge: Which is Right for You?
The best filter for your pool depends on your priorities and budget. If you’re looking for a reliable, low-maintenance option with good filtration, a sand filter is a great choice. If you prioritize the absolute cleanest water and don’t mind the higher maintenance and costs, a cartridge filter might be the better fit.
Spotlight on Sand Filters & The Benefits of Glass Media
Sand filters have long been trusted by pool owners for their effectiveness and simplicity. Upgrading to glass media takes their performance to the next level. Glass media offers:
- Finer Filtration: Traps particles as small as 5 microns, resulting in sparkling clear water.
- Reduced Backwashing: Less frequent backwashing saves water and time.
- Longer Lifespan: Glass media is more durable than sand, potentially lasting the lifetime of your filter.
Conclusion
Choosing the right filter and media is crucial for maintaining a clean and healthy pool. While cartridge filters offer superior filtration, sand filters, especially with glass media, provide a compelling combination of performance, affordability, and low maintenance. With the right filter in place, you can spend less time worrying about maintenance and more time enjoying your pool!